Monsters Moving On
| 2025 | Illeana Cosillos | New Mexico Highlands University |
| Taylor Christensen |
Abilene Christian University |
|
| Jolissa Valdez | New Mexico Highlands University | |
| Marianna Zumerle | Texas A&M, Kingsville | |
| 2024 | Mariah Cunningham | Sterling, KS |
| Braelynn Kaulu-ChoyFoo | Sterling, KS | |
| Alex Genty | Ottawa University-Kansas | |
| 2023 | Cassidy Morrow | Oklahoma Baptist University |
| Cheyenne Cunningham | Sterling, KS | |
| Christa Zagala | Colorado Mesa State College | |
| Emma Roach | Colorado Mesa State College | |
| Jaileen Mancha | New Mexico State University | |
| Madison Chavez | University of Arizona (Criminal Justice) | |
| Mieya Andres | University of the Southwest | |
| Nohea Akana | Sterling, KS | |
| Lauren Salcido | Adams State University | |
| Savannah Clausen | Cal State Bakersfield | |
| 2022 | Solymar Navarro | Pima (Nursing) |
| Alondra Lugo | University of Arizona (Criminal Justice) | |
| Alyssa Loera | NMSU (Nursing) | |
| Kayla Lunar | New Mexico State | |
| Baillie Murry | King University | |
| 2021 | Gabby Romero | Park University/Gilbert |
| 2019 | Hailey Alexis Yamaguchi | Antelope Valley College |
| Kaila Burnett | Western NM University | |
| Carman Angulo | Kansas Wesleyan | |
| Brianna McGinnis | Kansas Wesleyan | |
| 2018 | Alyssa Salud-Mendoza | Western NM University |
| Laugatausala Pedebone | Portland State | |
| Bailey Rominger | Chadron State, NE | |
| Vevesi Liilii | Hawaii Hilo | |
| Taylor Hollestelle | Fort Lewis | |
| Kendall Rauk | Fort Lewis | |
| 2017 | Isabel Mejia | Hawaii Hilo |
| 2016 | Claudia Lopez | Cal State San Bernadino |