Monsters Moving On
| 2025 | Armari Carraway | Charleston Southern | D1 |
| JT Elder | Eastern Illinois | D1 | |
| Kaden Ericksen | Northern Colorado | D1 | |
| Felix Smedejback | Arkansas Monticello | D2 | |
| Xavier Baker | Alaska Fairbanks | D2 | |
| Mathok Chol | Western Florida University | D2 | |
| Tarrance Warren | Barry University | D2 | |
| Jamare Childs | Lewis & Clark State | NAIA | |
| Dijarn Russell-Walters | NAIA | ||
| 2024 | Dallon Morgan | Central Washington University | D2 |
| Leigh Rickwood-Pit | Northern Arizona University | D1 | |
| Akok Machar | University of Texas Tyler | D2 | |
| Raysean Seamster | University of Texas Arlington | D1 | |
| Noah Ogoli | Xavier University of Louisiana | NAIA | |
| Anton Bonke | Providence | D1 | |
| 2023 | Theo Seng | Troy University | D1 |
| JJ White | Mayville State | NAIA | |
| Jerry Boston | Ecclesiastical College | D2 | |
| Rylan Van Komen | BYU (football) | D1 | |
| 2022 | Corey Boston | Concord University | D2 |
| 2016 | Jaraan Lands | University of Albany | D1 |
| 2015 | Reggie Oliver | Quinnipiac | D1 |
| Tyler Chaisson | Mid-american Nazerene | NAIA | |
| 2014 | Dom Hunter | University of Alaska Anchorage | D2 |
| Jon Orr | Colorado Mesa University | D2 | |
| Marcus Palmer | Central Connecticut | D1 | |
| Will Bynum | Montana State | D1 | |
| Nikola Kecman | Ohio State | D1 | |
| Chop Tang | Wisconsin Green Bay | D1 | |
| Roman Andrea | New Mexico Highlands | D2 | |
| Nate Pollard | Maryland Eastern Shore | D1 | |
| Taylor Stafford | University of Evansville | D1 | |
| D'Juan Miller | Loyal-Chicago University | D1 | |
| 2012 | Mike Mckevie | University of Alaska Anchorage | D2 |
| 2011 | Mike James | Lamar University | D1 |
| 2010 | Mario Gill | University of Alaska Anchorage | D2 |
| Stephan Heard | University of Alaska Anchorage | D2 | |
| 2009 | |||
| 2008 | Dontae Bryant | University of San Francisco | D1 |
| 1996 | Dennis Griffin | University of Colorado | D1 |
| Vonte Carter | Portland State University | D1 | |
| DeAndre Love | Northwestern State University | D1 | |
| Davon Bolton | Northern Arizona State University | D1 | |
| Rayvaughn Bolton | Central Washington University | D2 |